“ The fish for two meal had excellent fish and coleslaw. The French fries tasted like run of the mill frozen fries. We ooted to pay extra the 2nd time we ate there and for a $3 up charge got the onion rings. They were very good, except we got only 4 or 5 small rings apiece for the uncharged ”

“ I went to Rubbin' Butts at the recommendation of two different people I met at an Arcade Bar. When I stepped in it seemed like a generic Barbecue place, and honestly it really is. The walls don't have much decor and was mostly just set up with TVs displaying several different shows and football games. I saw 1 staff member the entire time I was there which was odd, but she did a fantastic job of serving me. I got a Spicy Pulled Pork Sandwich and was given the low down on their 3 signature sauces. The spicy sauce they have mixed with their sweet sauce was exactly what I was hunting for. Other than the plain Jane style I thought this place was fantastic. ”

“ Had WDRB certificate and wanted to try this place out. We got 20 wings. 10 with Rudder Hot (great spice!) and 10 BBQ sauce. Also got the family meal that had smoked pulled chicken, pulled pork, brisket, two baked potatoes and a slab of ribs. Every item was well smoked. So tender. Also got the brisket quesadilla. The bourbon BBQ sauce is excellent and a little spicy. They give you slices of bread but I wish they would serve buns with the family meal. They did forgetthe butter and sour cream. With the coupon the bill came to $77. Rounded up to $100 for the tip. Got everything to-go but I still leave a nice tip. Worth going! Great smoked food. ”

“ One of my favorite BBQ places to eat at. Every time it's reliable and consistent quality. Great prices! ”

“ An absolute must take family friendly restaurant. This is a seat yourself restaurant and I do have some questions on how they know when someone comes in but I assume that they have someone that hears a doorbell go off. Better than Marks Feedstore, better than American Smokehouse, and we really like both of those. We talked with this amazing bartender her name was either Lisa or Michelle, she had bright white hair and she was incredibly amazing at answering all our questions very friendly she was running the bar area by herself she probably had 20 or 30 people in there and she stayed on top of it. The drinks were kept very cold and refills came on time. She had great recommendations. We ended up trying the potato skins that they top with pork barbecue it comes with sour cream and the sauces are on the table. I really like their version of the mustard sauce, they also have a sweet baby Ray's sauce, and then they have a spicier one that they make in house that I definitely could not handle but my husband locked it. We plan on going back. We did some thing at the end of our mail that we don't typically do we re-ordered the mill to take home so that our parents could enjoy it because we loved it that much. It was rockstar food it was rockstar service. ”

“ Rubbin' Butts has been on my 'To Try' list for awhile and I finally had an opportunity to check them out. They are located in a strip of shopping stores. A sign on the wall just inside the door says "seat yourself." The booths have hard bench seating and their tables have padded chairs. The TVs look like at least 65 or 70 inches to me and there are a lot of them. My granddaughter and I ordered a Full Slab of Ribs and split them. I ordered the potato salad and baked beans. She got the fries. Then she pranked me. She told me the fries were really spicy so I grabbed the red squeeze bottle and put some ketchup on my plate first and tried them. They were one of the spiciest things I've ever ate. Truth was the real ketchup bottle was hidden behind the roll of paper towels and the red squeeze bottle was the spicy BBQ sauce. The fries were fine as in normal. She got me good. She made the same mistake though and then decided I should share her misery, lol. The ribs were excellent as were the baked beans and fries. I didn't care for the potato salad. There was nothing wrong with it; it just didn't appeal to my palate. And we both enjoyed the large order of fries. Next time she wants to try the Pulled Chicken Sandwich and I would like to try the Pulled Pork Sandwich or the Shrimp Basket. ”

“ I've been here twice for lunch. It's been slow mid-week which means that the service is that much faster. They have a lunch special in addition to the main menu. I've stuck with that each time. You get a sandwich with their limited choice of meat and their homemade chips. I've had the pulled pork and meatloaf so far. Previously, I also took a pint of mac and cheese home for my daughter. She ate the entire thing so that's also a rave review. This is more Memphis, Indiana than Memphis, Tennessee but it is still high on the hog for barbecue in Indiana. If you're in Sellersburg, it is a must-see. ”